Just in: Who Could Replace James Cook? Bills’ Potential 2026 NFL Draft Targets at Running Back.
As James Cook nears the end of his rookie contract, the Buffalo Bills may face a critical decision in the 2026 offseason. With salary cap management and team needs in mind, Buffalo could turn to the NFL Draft to find a fresh, cost-effective replacement at running back. Let’s explore top college prospects who could fit into the Bills’ evolving offense.
1. Nicholas Singleton – Penn State
Singleton has NFL-ready size (6’0”, 227 lbs) and elite speed. Known for his ability to hit the hole quickly and break away for long gains, he also brings a physical edge in short-yardage situations. His combination of power and explosiveness makes him a top-tier 2026 draft candidate.
2. Justice Haynes – Alabama
Following in the footsteps of past Crimson Tide stars, Haynes is a patient runner with great field vision and contact balance. He’s a strong inside runner but also effective in the passing game, which would make him a seamless fit in Buffalo’s offense.
3. Jayden Ott – California
Ott stands out for his dual-threat ability. In addition to his production as a runner, he excels as a receiver out of the backfield—something the Bills heavily rely on. His shiftiness and reliable hands could make him a favorite target for Josh Allen.
4. Jeremiyah Love – Notre Dame
A rising star with blazing speed and natural instincts, Love profiles as a big-play threat every time he touches the ball. He could bring a dynamic edge to the Bills’ backfield similar to what Cook currently provides.
5. Makhi Hughes – Oregon
Hughes is a tough South, no-nonsense runner with great lower-body strength. He thrives in zone schemes and could develop into a reliable every-down back with the right coaching.
In Conclusion, Whether Buffalo opts to re-sign James Cook or move on, they’ll have excellent options in the 2026 NFL Draft. With Josh Allen still in his prime, pairing him with a young, explosive back could keep the Bills’ offense among the league’s elite for years to come.
